Arizona appeals court upholds post-loss assignment of property repair claims under HO policies

June 13, 2018by CDSAdmin0

Homeowners hired a water restoration contractor to repair storm damage. The Work Order Agreement contained an assignment of the homeowners’ benefits and causes of action under any applicable insurance policy. Repair invoices were submitted to Homeowners’ insurer, Farmers, who paid what it determined to be the reasonable value of the services, but less than the invoice amount. The contractor, as assignee, sued Farmers for the balance.

Farmers moved to dismiss the lawsuit, arguing it was based upon an invalid assignment. According to Farmers, the policy’s anti-assignment provision precluded the assignment of rights under the policy. The provision states that the insureds’ “interest in this policy may not be transferred to another person without [Farmers’] written consent.”

The contractor countered that the insureds did not assign an interest in the policy, but rather a claim or “chose in action” arising from the policy. The trial court denied Farmers’ motion to dismiss and Farmers filed a Special Action.

The Court of Appeals accepted Special Action jurisdiction because there were over 150 similar cases filed in its jurisdiction. Siding with the contractor, the Court held that a post-loss assignment of the insureds’ claim is valid because, at that point, it is not the policy itself that is assigned, but rather a claim under the policy.

Farmers warned that the Court’s holding, coupled with the broad language of the assignment, would allow insureds to assign not only the collection of a repair invoice, but also extra-contractual claims. In response, the Court specifically limited its holding to a post-loss assignment of contract claims.

Farmers Insurance Exchange v. The Honorable David Udall , et al . , No. 1 CA-SA 18-0081, 2018 WL 2931906 (Ariz. Ct. App. Div. 1 June 12, 2018).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

https://cdslawfirm.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/logo-cds-1-320x221.png
Locations

PHOENIX

Christian, Dichter & Sluga, P.C.
Suite 860
Phoenix, AZ 85004
602.792.1700

_

LAS VEGAS

Christian, Johnson, Sluga & Mushmeche, LLC
8985 S. Eastern Ave.
Suite 200
Las Vegas, NV 89123
702.362.6666

Social Networks
Meet and greet us on our social media accounts, or just say hi.
https://cdslawfirm.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/04/floating_image_05.png

© 2016-2024. Christian, Dichter & Sluga, P.C.

The act of visiting or communicating with Christian, Dichter & Sluga, P.C., via this website or by email does not constitute an attorney-client relationship. Communications from non-clients via this website are not subject to client confidentiality or attorney-client privilege. Further, the articles, discussion, commentary, forms and sample documentation contained in this website are offered as general guidance only and are not to be relied upon as specific legal advice. For legal advice on a specific matter, please consult with an attorney who is knowledgeable and experienced in the appropriate area. The lawyers listed in this website practice law only in the jurisdictions in which they are admitted. This website is subject to the Arizona Rules of Professional Conduct.